Pacifist lawsuits: not just for Japan any more

May 14th, 2008 by Joe Jones
Joe

It seems like every few months there’s yet another court ruling as to the constitutionality of Japan’s defense forces. Apparently, Americans are following suit with regard to the Iraq war.

New Jersey Peace Action et al. v. Bush, represented by the Constitutional Law Clinic at Rutgers University Law School-Newark, alleges that the war violates article I, section 8 of the U.S. Constitution, which assigns to Congress the authority to declare war.

Clinic director Frank Askin said the framers at the 1787 constitutional convention denied war-making powers to the president except in response to sudden attacks when Congress might not have time to react quickly.

“The founders were very clear that only Congress could make that awesome decision,” he said in a statement. “They [members of Congress] were not permitted to delegate that power to the president and thus be able later to disclaim responsibility for a decision gone bad.”

Interesting (but, I suspect, futile) arguments in the full article.

Related Posts

  • Another Iraq War lawsuit bites the dust
  • Japanese Hostage Seems Like a Cool Guy
  • Uncontent with barking up trees, Chinese plaintiffs switch to pissing in wind
  • Adam J. Richards disappointed in court decision in favor of Borat
  • Aso’s plan to de-Shintoize Yasukuni
  • 4 Responses to 'Pacifist lawsuits: not just for Japan any more'

    1. Bryce Says:

      The Constitution doesn’t say that Congress needs to vote for a bill with the words ‘declaration of war’ in it. They voted to fund the war, so that would be a pretty clear indication of their intent. I can’t see them getting far with that particular suit.

    2. Curzon Says:

      We’ve had pacifist lawsuits such as this for centuries, but they always lose.

    3. Joe Jones Says:

      Yeah, no doubt. I’m just mildly amused.

    4. Luke Says:

      “awesome decision”..
      It’s a shame that word can’t be read without Keanu Reeve’s voice in your head anymore. Like, totally, dude….

    Leave a Reply

    We are currently using the Akismet spam filter, which sometimes eats legitimate comments, particularly those containing URLs. If you are having trouble getting a comment up, try splitting the URL into two parts, or failing that, email one of us. Note that we only deliberately block comments that appear to be spam.